
There has been an explosion of biblical commentary publishing in the last three decades; so much so, that a buyer needs some help to wade through the sea of availability.
(And, BTW, Peter Davids --- himself a writer of scholarly commentaries --- was interviewed on this blog September 1 concerning the explosion. Read his comments
here.)
Over the years I have discovered some bibliographic resources that help me purchase the commentaries I need. Not only do I get guidance on the quality and theological slants of the commentaries, there is the added benefit of saving a lot of money by avoiding less-than-helpful volumes.
Because of the great respect I have for Gordon Fee, I always consult his commentary recommendations listed in the back of his best-selling book,
How to Read the Bible for All Its Worth, third edition (Zondervan). Fee recommends the New Testament commentaries, and his co-author, Douglas Stuart, does the same for the Old Testament books. One minor drawback to this resource is that the most recent edition of
How to Read ... was published in 2003. The pace of commentary writing is such that recommendations given in 2003 are somewhat dated.
Like Fee and Stuart, Donald Carson and Tremper Longman III are scholars who, in addition to their own commentary writing, provide evaluation of commentaries. Carson's
New Testament Commentary Survey (Baker Academic) is now in its sixth edition (2007), and Longman's
Old Testament Commentary Survey (Baker Academic) is in its fourth edition (2007).
As far as being current as possible, five Denver Seminary professors help by publishing their recommendations online annually. The
Annotated Old Testament Bibliography for 2010 was prepared by Richard Hess, Helene Dallaire, and M. Daniel Carroll Rodas. The
New Testament Exegesis Bibliography for 2010 was prepared by Craig Blomberg and William Klein.
Other resources that may be of some help include:
- The late John Glynn's Commentary & Reference Survey (Kregel Publications).
- John Dyer's website, BestCommentaries.com, which collates the evaluations of Longman, Carson, Glynn, and others.
- Wheaton professor John Walton offers his recommendations here
- Recommendations by OT scholar Allen Ross are included at the end of this paper
- Recommendations by OT scholar John Goldingay are included the end of this paper
- Recommendations by OT scholar Ralph Klein can be found here